Sometimes the most valuable treasures are hiding in the everyday—whether it’s in an attic, a thrift shop, or a handful of loose change. This is the astonishing true account of how a weathered Buffalo Nickel, once used to pay for a pizza, became a national exhibit worth over $600,000.
Pizza Night and an Overlooked Coin
In 2007, a hungry teenager in Pennsylvania scrounged together some coins to pay for a late-night pizza delivery. Among the handful of change was an old Buffalo Nickel—one of many coins that had long faded from attention. Like most people, he didn’t think twice about it.
Buffalo Nickels, minted from 1913 to 1938, were once common pocket change. But this particular coin held a secret detail that would soon be discovered.
A Rare Find in a Coin Shop
The nickel eventually landed at a small coin shop, where the owner—a veteran coin collector—noticed something curious. While the date appeared worn, there was a faint doubling visible on the buffalo’s image.
Upon closer inspection, it was confirmed to be a 1918/7-D overdate Buffalo Nickel—an incredibly rare minting error. The coin’s date had been struck over a 1917 die, creating a distinct double-date impression. Fewer than 200 of these coins have ever been found, making it one of the rarest errors in American coinage.
A Coin’s Climb to Fame
After being passed between private collectors for years, the coin’s legend grew. In 2024, it went up for auction at Stack’s Bowers Galleries, one of the most respected names in numismatics.
Despite its worn appearance, the coin triggered intense competition among bidders. Its rarity and fascinating backstory pushed the final price to an astonishing $601,000.
A Gift to the Public
Though the buyer remained anonymous, they made a generous decision—donating the coin to the American Numismatic Museum in Colorado Springs. Today, this once-overlooked nickel rests securely behind glass, drawing crowds and admiration from across the country.
A plaque beside it tells its story: how a simple pizza order led to the discovery of a hidden national treasure.
Why This Coin Captivates
Buffalo Nickels already hold a special place in American history with their detailed images of a Native American and a powerful buffalo. But the 1918/7-D overdate stands apart—symbolizing the magic that can be found in the everyday and reminding us that remarkable stories often begin in the most unexpected ways.
Look Before You Toss
How often do we empty our pockets without a second glance? This story is proof that a closer look could change your life. Whether it’s under your car seat or in a jar on the counter, your spare change might be hiding something truly rare.
Because even a slice of pizza can become the first step in an extraordinary journey.
FAQs
What is a 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickel?
It’s a rare minting error where a 1918 date was struck over a 1917 die, creating a double-date appearance on the coin.
How many 1918/7-D Buffalo Nickels exist?
Fewer than 200 are believed to survive today, making it one of the scarcest U.S. coin errors ever discovered.
Why is this nickel worth over $600,000?
Its value comes from its rarity, historical error, and the compelling story behind how it was found and auctioned.
Where is the coin now displayed?
It is now on exhibit at the American Numismatic Museum in Colorado Springs, thanks to a generous anonymous donation.